Abstract
Identity-related harm is widespread among youth: one nationally representative study found that approximately 1.3 million youth aged 12 to 17 experienced peer harm based on race, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, or gender identity. Schools and policymakers have largely responded through exclusionary discipline and criminalization, framing such harm as bullying or, increasingly, as a hate crime. Yet mounting evidence suggests these punitive approaches do little to deter harm and may deepen existing racial disparities in discipline. Restorative justice (RJ) has emerged as a promising alternative, emphasizing accountability, repair, and community healing over punishment. Little research has documented how RJ practitioners with expertise in bias-related harm navigate the identity dimensions of this work. This study addresses that gap through interviews with 25 RJ practitioners selected for their experience and expertise in utilizing RJ to address identity-related harm among youth. Findings will document how practitioners conceptualize identity-related harm, balance individual accountability with attention to structural and systemic conditions, and understand effectiveness. Results will inform scholarship on restorative justice and offer practical guidance for schools, RJ training organizations, and policymakers seeking non-punitive alternatives to bias-related harm among youth, including LGBTQ+ youth and youth of color, disproportionately affected by both identity-related harm and punitive responses to it.
Field
Social Welfare/Luskin School of Public Affairs
Team

Emily M. Waters is an incoming Doctoral Student in the Department of Social Welfare at the UCLA Luskin School of Public Affairs and works as a Policy and Research Advisor at the Transgender Law Center. Emily has extensive experience conducting community-based research and policy advocacy on issues related to queer and trans rights, with a particular focus on domestic, sexual, and state violence. She focuses on developing and advocating for policy solutions that move power and resources into community and challenge systemic oppression rather than reinforce the carceral state. Her work can be found in The New York Times, HuffPost, and The Advocate.

Dr. Laura Wray-Lake’s research is primarily focused on youth civic engagement. The starting point for this research is the assumption that adolescents and young adults hold abundant potential and act as positive change agents and address society’s problems on local, national, and global scales. In Dr. Wray-Lake’s work, civic engagement is intentionally broadly defined to include behaviors as well as values, skills, knowledge, and motivations; political and helping-oriented forms of engagement; and informal and formal ways of being civically engaged. Her work also prioritizes young people’s own definitions of civic engagement, as youth are continually reimagining ways of being civically engaged that align with their opportunities and contexts.

