Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) enables the production of novel and salient groupings of individuals that are both central to information capitalism and an existential challenge to the framework of American equality law. Using diverse techniques and widely sourced data, AI is used to assemble people into novel, presumably coherent groups. Membership in these groups, in turn, determines individuals’ differential exposure to hate, bias, and discrimination on a systematic scale. Processes of targeted advertising, healthcare service allocation, access to financial credit, and so-called “personalized pricing” for consumer goods, are determined by membership in these AI-constructed groups. This project surveys the emerging equality law frameworks aimed at protecting AI groups from hate and structural discrimination. It explains how these emerging frameworks mistakenly narrow regulatory concern to the ways in which AI groups overlap with traditionally protected classes, thereby permitting hate and discrimination against members of AI groups that are not also identified with legally protected classes. The project critiques the assembly of AI groups as a racially discriminatory and unavoidable feature of informational capitalism, which extracts value from processes of classification, essentialization, and differential treatment. The project concludes with law and policy prescriptions to protect AI groups from hate in the digital age.

Field

Law

Extramural Partners

CADRE (Community Asset Development Redefining Education) Black and Brown Families

Team

Fanna Gamal profile picture
Fanna Gamal

Fanna Gamal’s work examines how the law distributes resources needed for individual and collective well-being. She researches and writes in the areas of law and technology, information privacy law, education law, and critical race theory. In addition to teaching in the law school’s Critical Race Studies program, Gamal directs the Community Lawyering in Education Clinic. She was previously a Binder Fellow at UCLA School of Law, an attorney and clinical supervisor at the East Bay Community Law Center, the recipient of an Equal Justice Works fellowship, and a Fellow at New America.

She received her J.D. from UC Berkeley School of Law where she was an editor of the California Law Review. Gamal’s writing has been published or is forthcoming in the Stanford Law Review, UCLA Law Review, Columbia Journal of Gender & Law, and California Law Review among others.